TideRock Financial is proud to be a fee-only registered investment advisor (RIA) and fiduciary for its clients. But this important distinction and its advantages for the clients we serve can sometimes be overlooked. A story in today’s Wall Street Journal on the different breeds of financial advisors and how they charge their clients summarizes this issue quite succinctly:
“The distinction in how advisers are paid could affect the advice they give you. Regulations require financial advisers who charge commissions to make sure a product is appropriate for an investor before selling it, but RIAs are held to a higher standard: They are fiduciaries, meaning they have an obligation to think about what investments would best serve the client. Also, fee-only advisers are paid only by their clients, which means they have no incentive to sell you particular financial products.”
The article goes on to warn investors about the “incentives” some advisors may have to steer clients into a particular fund or investment product – whether it’s a fat commission or a bonus for hitting a certain sales target. Again, as a fee-only advisor, TideRock eliminates these conflicts of interest for its clients.
To read the entire Wall Street Journal story, please read “Questions to Ask Your Adviser About Fees”.
“1. How are you registered?
Advisers’ pay and their obligations to clients are related to whether they are registered with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority or the federal Securities and Exchange Commission.
Finra-registered advisers—”registered representatives” of securities firms—typically are paid by commissions when investors buy or sell securities. Advisers who charge fees for advice generally are “registered investment advisers,” or RIAs, overseen by either the SEC or state securities regulators. Many individuals wear one hat for part of their business and a different hat for the other. If you deal with them in both capacities, you may pay them both an advisory fee and trading commissions.
The distinction in how advisers are paid could affect the advice they give you. Regulations require financial advisers who charge commissions to make sure a product is appropriate for an investor before selling it, but RIAs are held to a higher standard: They are fiduciaries, meaning they have an obligation to think about what investments would best serve the client. Also, fee-only advisers are paid only by their clients, which means they have no incentive to sell you particular financial products.
2. What am I paying you and your firm directly?
This can include commissions to trade securities and fees that may be set by the hour or as a percentage of your assets being managed by the adviser.
Knowing exactly what these charges are allows you to factor those costs into your investment behavior. For instance, if you know how big the commission is that you pay every time a trade is made on your behalf, you can decide if there is a point where those fees start to eat up too much of the gains you seek from switching investments. Or if your adviser charges an hourly fee, knowing what that fee is can help you decide how much consultation you really need.
Sometimes there is a free lunch, or at least an appetizer: A financial specialist sometimes will provide some free advice now in hopes of selling you products down the road. Many offer an initial portfolio review for no upfront cost.
3. What payments are built into the products I may buy from you?
You also want to know about compensation that isn’t as obvious. There’s almost always a cost for advice, even if it’s built into the cost of the products you end up buying, says Dan Keady, director of financial planning at financial-services firm TIAA-CREF.
For instance, all mutual funds charge for their expenses, which can include compensation for sellers. But those charges vary widely, and higher charges produce lower returns for investors, so it pays to shop around. Also, a single mutual fund may be available in several share classes with different fees.
Knowing about the fees built into products also can help you spot potential conflicts of interest. A firm benefits if its staffers sell products the firm designs or oversees. Those products aren’t necessarily bad for you, but it’s worth scrutinizing their charges to see if they compare favorably with those of alternatives.
When investors buy or sell mutual funds through discount brokerage firms’ “no transaction fee” marketplaces, part of the funds’ expense charges are going to compensate the brokerage firms. If you know what those charges are, you may be able to find a cheaper class of the same fund or a similar fund with lower charges from another provider.
In the case of individual bonds, firms usually collect the difference between the price at which they buy the bonds and the price at which they resell them to investors. This “spread” is also assessed when investors trade foreign currencies through a brokerage firm. Spreads vary, so be aware that you might be able to find a better price from another broker.
Investors may also be charged if their adviser invests part of their account in a hedge fund or private-equity fund. Typically this charge will be obvious. But the investor may not be told about any commission the adviser earns from the funds, a potential conflict of interest, so you should be sure a better deal isn’t available elsewhere.
Another potential conflict of interest: Some advisers may get incentives—a trip or a bonus, for instance—if they hit certain sales targets or sell specific products. There’s no way for you to know if that’s the case, but knowing that it could be is another reason to shop around to make sure you’re getting the best possible deal.”